Coincidentally, I met with an intercultural situation recently, while accompanying my father to his forwarders’ warehouse.
It was lunchtime for the staff when we arrived and the staff - five Malays and two Chinese- were gathered together tucking in their food. Both my father and I were astonished by the scene that greeted us - a box of Bak Kwa (barbequed pork, a delicacy during Chinese New Year) was laid on the table and a Chinese lady, seated between two Malays, was enjoying a piece of Bak Kwa. All five Malays ate their food in silence. Seeing this, my father and I kept our distance.
After the Malays had left, with the last casting a displeased look at the Chinese lady, my father casually asked the Chinese lady if she had offended the Malays by her action. It is against their Muslim religion to come into contact with pork.
To our surprise and disgust, the lady replied that each individual has the freedom to eat whatever, whenever and wherever they desire, regardless if they were Malays or Chinese or Indians. Besides, the office is a neutral place and hence, she felt that there was no offence being made to her Malay colleagues.
Not only was I shocked, I was also angry at the lady’s reply. She had simply showed no sensitivity to the feelings of her Malay colleagues. From my interpretation of the expressions on the faces of the Malay employees, they probably felt somewhat uncomfortable by her acts, but not wishing to create any conflict, chose to tolerant the lady’s acts and eat their lunch in silence.
On the way home, I asked my father for this opinion of the scene. My father explained that his Muslim Malay friends have expressed their thoughts on such issues and as Singapore is a multiracial society, it is not uncommon for them to encounter such situations. Most of them, especially those with a staunch belief in their religion, feel uncomfortable seated at the same table with people of other races eating pork. However, if given no choice, they would still accept their differences quietly. On the other hand, many of the Chinese people who have Muslim friends try not to order any pork when they are dining with the Muslims so as to show sensitivity to their culture.
Personally, I feel that it is important to be sensitive to each other’s culture, especially in a multiracial society like Singapore. Although people may be more tolerant here and choose to remain silent so as to avoid conflicts, it does not mean that their needs and feelings should be taken for granted like the incident at the warehouse. Racial harmony cannot be obtained within one day, but it only takes one second, one spark, one insensitive remark or person to destroy all the peace that Singapore is enjoying.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Dear Jolene,
ReplyDeleteI liked the post for its 'complete-ness'. I felt every aspect was clearly described.
As far as the situation itself is concerned, I always wonder, when will people realize that it is issues like religion that cause world wars?
Cheers
Rohan
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDear Jolene,
ReplyDeleteI can totally picture the awkwardness of the entire scene as the Chinese lady munches on her Bak Kwa! And to think she had the audacity to disregard the feelings of her colleagues. It is evident that she was encroaching on the goodwill of her colleagues.
I must also commend the Malay colleagues for their patience and tolerance. It is only too easy for tension to mount into a conflict.
Dear Jolene,
ReplyDeleteI agree with your reflections over the incident.
Since the Malays keep their opinions to themselves, I felt the Chinese was behaving in a rude manner. There must be some gives and takes in such scenarios. If one party consistently demonstrates such insensitive behavior, conflict will be unavoidable.
I suppose the Chinese lady was fully aware of such practices?
Regards,
Godwin
Hi Jolene,
ReplyDeleteThis is a very well written post. It is very comprehensive and it clearly describes the emotions and feelings of the people involved.
Although the scenario mentioned is not very common in Singapore, at least to me, I have witnessed such scenario. In most cases, people tend to ignore such insensitive act. However, I feel that ignoring does not mean resolving. Intercultural clashes often arise when the initial stages of conflict experienced by members of a multicultural group, were not sufficiently or soonest addressed. Thus, I feel that it may be necessary for the Malays to express their feelings verbally to the Chinese lady in a courteous manner.
This reminds me of a recently conversation I had with my relatives, regarding cultural sensitivity. Everyone involved in the conversation agrees that cultural sensitivity is essential to maintain peace and harmony in a multicultural society, like Singapore. However, the question I want to post is whether culture sensitivity is practiced in other mono-cultural society. Some of my relatives think that it is practiced while some disagree to that.
An example raised to show the lack of practice in mono-cultural society is the French culture. I would first like to admit that I have little knowledge of the French culture. Quoting my uncle, the French place high emphasis on wine. As such, wine is often serves together with meals in restaurants, instead of water. Even if the restaurant is run by Muslims, they will still serve wine, despite their religion, which forbid them to consume alcohol. In my opinion, this is not a case of cultural insensitivity. France, being a non-Muslim country, does not have the obligation to accommodate other religious cultures and beliefs. On the hand, the Muslims should not impose on the host country to accommodate their values and beliefs. In other words, this is a case of mutual respect for each other. Therefore, I think people should be more tolerant towards each other religions and beliefs.
Hello Jolene,
ReplyDeleteAs much as I hate to say it, there was nothing wrong with that lady's reply.
But there was something wrong with that lady. The fact that she could ignore the discomfort felt by the Malays, due to her actions, suggests a very selfish attitude.
Your scenario highlighted selfishness and a blatant disregard for a possible compromise (in this case, the lady). But to be fair, her situation should be understood too. So in this case, we might need to know the underlying reason behind her actions.
Regards,
Kian Leong
Hello Jolene,
ReplyDeleteA classic example of how Singaporeans can be so culturally blind given that we live in a multi racial society.
I can only begin to picture the scene in my mind. The lady was extremely insensitive in her actions. Sad to say, her reply was politically correct. I would just like to ask, was the lady brought up and raised in Singapore? If so, it is really remarkable that she was so insensitive and ignorant to the practices of Muslims.
Cheers,
Joshua
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteExcellent post, Jolene, both in the clear, concise and complete telling and in the analysis. The scene you described was indeed quite shocking, more so as the lady seemed oblivious and defiant.
ReplyDeleteWas there any resolution? Or was that it?
Hi all, thanks for your comments.
ReplyDeleteTo Rohan,
I have always asked myself that question too when I come across readings on clashes/wars!
To Zhisheng:
Yes, thankfully the Malay colleagues were patient and tolerant, if not there would have been a big conflict.
To Godwin:
I am not sure if the Chinese lady was fully aware of such practices, but I think I can safely assume she knew, given our multi-racial society and given that she has been working with these Malay colleagues for some time already.
To Emily,
I totally agree with you on your stand that ignoring does not mean resolving. Yes, like all big quarrels, the outburst is usually the result of an accumulation of unhappiness caused by minor incidents. Thanks for sharing your story, I didn’t know Muslims cannot drink alcohol at all, a lesson for me!
To Kian Leong,
Your comment on the lady’s reply certainly did make me have second thoughts. I do see what you mean, yes, to some extent, I guess her answer was indeed politically correct, though it was also extremely insensitive.
To Joshua,
I am not sure if the lady was brought up and raised in Singapore, but like I told Godwin, I think I can safely assume she knew of such practices, even if she was not brought up and raised in Singapore, given our multi-racial society and given that she has been working with these Malay colleagues for some time already.
To Brad,
With regards to the scenario I came across, yes, that was it. The Malay colleagues did not want to create any trouble and chose to be tolerant, while on the other hand (sadly) the Chinese lady herself did not view her attitude as a problem. Hence, no big conflict arose from this incident.